Home >  News >  What to expect from James Gunn's Superman through the lens of All-Star Superman

What to expect from James Gunn's Superman through the lens of All-Star Superman

Authore: LillianUpdate:Feb 27,2025

Superman! Superman! Superman! The world echoes with the iconic chant, set to John Williams' powerful guitar riff. A hopeful new DC Cinematic Universe dawns in the first trailer for James Gunn's Superman film.

James Gunn's Superman, starring David Corensworth, soars into theaters July 11, 2025. Gunn serves as both writer and director, a role he initially hesitated to take on, initially planning only to pen the screenplay.

Gunn's script draws heavily from Grant Morrison's acclaimed All-Star Superman comic book, a 12-issue miniseries. This source material, known for its poignant depiction of Superman revealing his secrets to Lois Lane and confronting his own mortality, deeply resonated with Gunn, a longtime comic book enthusiast.

Inspired by arguably the greatest Superman comic ever written, what can we expect from this faithful adaptation?

Table of Contents

  • One of the greatest…
  • Grant Morrison: A Masterful and Concise Storyteller
  • A Gateway to the Silver Age of Superheroes
  • An Inventively Told Tale
  • A Story About People
  • Exploring Our Relationship with Past and Future
  • Blurring the Lines Between Narrative and Reader
  • A Testament to Boundless Optimism

Superman parentsImage: ensigame.com… All-Star Superman, by Morrison and Quietly, stands as one of the finest, if not the finest, Superman comics of the 21st century. This exploration aims to reignite enthusiasm for this masterpiece, both for newcomers and those who may have forgotten its brilliance.

Disclaimer: This analysis delves into All-Star Superman's narrative without shying away from potential spoilers. The excitement lies not in the unknown, but in the masterful storytelling. While plot details will be minimized, accompanying images and excerpts may reveal elements that some readers prefer to discover independently.

Here's why All-Star Superman deserves its accolades:

Grant Morrison: A Masterful and Concise Storyteller

Clark Kent transformationImage: ensigame.com

Morrison masterfully unfolds the narrative, humanizes characters, and even depicts Superman's sun-flight within the first issue, all while encapsulating the essence of the Superman mythos in remarkably few pages. This economical storytelling deserves close examination.

The opening page, with its eight words and four illustrations, encapsulates Superman's origin story with breathtaking brevity and impact. It's a potent distillation of love, new beginnings, hope, and faith in progress. The subsequent expansion adds layers of depth and complexity to these foundational elements.

The film adaptation highlights the challenge of Morrison's concise style. In one instance, the merging of two scenes inadvertently portrays Superman as responsible for several deaths.

Superman and LoisImage: ensigame.com

Morrison's minimalist approach persists throughout. The confrontation between Superman and Lex Luthor in issue #10, where Superman expresses hope for Luthor's redemption, is powerfully conveyed in just a few panels. Similarly, the difference between Jor-El and Superman is brilliantly illustrated through two panels showcasing their contrasting actions.

While not always the most concise dialogue writer, Morrison's language in All-Star Superman is precise and deliberate. He notably highlights the "haiku about unified field theory" exchanged between a Quantum scientist and Lex Luthor.

A Gateway to the Silver Age of Superheroes

Superman at the sunImage: ensigame.com

Contemporary superhero comics have largely strived to distance themselves from the Silver Age's legacy. Navigating this complex history is challenging, especially given the often-absurd elements of that era.

All-Star Superman acknowledges this legacy. It suggests that we build upon the shoulders of giants, even those we might initially find humorous. Understanding the past, whether it's Dostoevsky or the Silver Age of comics, provides context for the evolution of the art form.

Superman at Kent's graveImage: ensigame.com

However, simple nostalgia isn't the goal. Morrison and Quitely translate the Silver Age into a contemporary language, utilizing its techniques and tropes with a modern sensibility.

An Inventively Told Tale

Supermans from different dimensionsImage: ensigame.com

A unique challenge in Superman stories is that he rarely needs to fight. Most superhero narratives use physical conflict to express various themes, but Superman's overwhelming power necessitates a different approach.

Morrison cleverly addresses this. Many conflicts are resolved quickly, focusing on the emotional and intellectual dimensions rather than brute force. The "new defenders of Earth" arc, for example, tests Superman's ability to save, not just defeat, his adversaries.

Superman fights Lex LuthorImage: ensigame.com

The confrontation with Lex Luthor highlights this shift in focus. Superman seeks redemption, not destruction. Even Solaris, a formidable foe, is dispatched efficiently, reflecting established continuity.

Morrison's genius lies in condensing the grandeur of Superman's mythos into a concise narrative. The story encompasses epic battles, personal triumphs, and profound moral dilemmas.

A Story About People

Lois becomes SuperwomanImage: ensigame.com

As Superman faces his mortality, his reflections center on his relationships, not his achievements. All-Star Superman prioritizes the perspectives of Lois, Jimmy Olsen, and Lex Luthor, showcasing Superman's impact on their lives. The narrative emphasizes the human connections that define Superman's legacy.

The focus on supporting characters mirrors the reader's relationship with Superman. We're less interested in his battles than in his impact on the lives he touches. The story explores "what if" scenarios, examining alternative paths in Superman's life.

A Story About Our Relationship with the Past and the Future

Superman reflects on his pastImage: ensigame.com

All-Star Superman masterfully explores the interplay between past and future. The narrative uses the established chronology of Superman's history as a springboard for exploring themes of legacy and change. It shows that neither escaping nor clinging to the past leads to true progress. Learning from the past is key to shaping the future.

Blurring the Lines Between Narrative and Reader

Clark Kent on workImage: ensigame.com

Morrison's work often employs metafictional techniques. All-Star Superman directly engages the reader, breaking the fourth wall. The narrative addresses the reader directly, placing us within the story's world. This creates a unique level of intimacy and immersion.

Superman in skyImage: ensigame.com

The climax of this interaction occurs in the final issue, where Lex Luthor directly addresses the reader, prompting reflection on the nature of the universe and our relationship with Superman. The narrative consistently invites the reader to experience the world through Superman's eyes.

A Testament to Boundless Optimism

Lex Luthor finally understandsImage: ensigame.com

All-Star Superman explores the process of canon formation within the Superman mythos. The twelve feats Superman undertakes create a reader-constructed canon, mirroring the way fans and creators build upon existing narratives. This meta-narrative adds another layer of depth to the story.

Superman and LoisImage: ensigame.com

These twelve feats, ranging from defeating Time to curing cancer, ultimately reveal the epic scope of Morrison's vision. It's not just a story; it's a testament to boundless optimism and the enduring power of hope. Gunn's adaptation has the potential to capture this essence, creating a bold and memorable cinematic experience.